|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Rev. Sun Myung Moon:
There are moments in history that pass quietly, unnoticed by the world—and yet, they carry the power to heal centuries. I believe this is one of those moments.
We sit here today, not in judgment, but in reflection. Not in opposition, but in search. Three generations of North Korea’s leadership—President Kim Il Sung, General Kim Jong Il, and Marshal Kim Jong Un—have accepted this invitation not because they must, but because they may. That alone is a seed of peace.
I have always believed that true leadership is not measured by military strength or global fear, but by how deeply one can love and uplift their people. In the eyes of Heaven, we are not rulers and citizens—we are all children of God, called to live as one family under the sky.
This conversation is not political. It is personal. It is spiritual. And it is long overdue.
The Korean Peninsula has wept for generations. North and South have grown apart in mind, in culture, in destiny. But no wall is eternal—not even the one carved into the 38th parallel. Today, we gather not to debate history, but to reclaim humanity. To ask what remains when power fades. To ask: What does it mean to be remembered—not by the world, but by your own people, and by God?
Let this dialogue be a place of courage. Let truth be spoken without fear. Let love, however unfamiliar, be allowed into the room.
May this be the first conversation of many, not between enemies—but between brothers.
(Note: This is an imaginary conversation, a creative exploration of an idea, and not a real speech or event.)
Topic 1: The Purpose of Power — Why Do We Rule?
Moderator: Rev. Sun Myung Moon
Rev. Moon (gently, with the voice of a father):
My dear friends, I welcome you here not as judge, but as witness to history. Three generations of Korea's leadership gathered under one roof—a rare and sacred moment. Let us begin not with what you’ve done, but why you did it. Tell me, from the depths of your heart: Why do you believe you were meant to rule?
Kim Il Sung:
I did not seek to rule—I was called. Our nation lay in ruins after colonial chains and world war. My power was born from resistance, forged in revolution. We needed a protector, a father, and in that absence, I stood. I ruled to raise a country that could never be enslaved again. But power, Reverend Moon, is like iron in the forge—it must be wielded carefully, or it breaks the very hands that hold it.
Kim Jong Un:
For me, it began as inheritance. But that’s not enough to justify rule. I had to grow into it. I asked myself, Is power only about fear? About missiles and loyalty? I feared irrelevance more than war. In this age, power must evolve. Our people want pride, yes—but also dignity. They want bread with their banners. I rule not to dominate, but to steer the ship through storms my grandfather could not foresee.
Kim Jong Il:
Rule is not a metaphor. It's mechanics. Survival. If you blink, you’re gone. I ruled in the shadow of collapse—the Soviet fall, famine, betrayal. My purpose was simple: prevent the death of our system. Keep the heart beating, even if it meant tightening the veins. My power was not about vision—it was about preservation. And preservation requires discipline over sentiment.
Rev. Moon (gently challenging):
But my friends, if power begins with protection and preservation, must it always end in control? Let me ask you now: What does true leadership require beyond strength?
Kim Jong Il:
Control, yes—but also clarity. You must know what you cannot allow. Softness invites collapse. The world is not kind to the weak. And yet… I confess, I sometimes wondered if fear alone could hold a nation. In my quietest hours, I wanted to trust my people more—but fear was louder.
Kim Il Sung:
True leadership is not fear, but vision. The people must feel your presence—not only in statues, but in their fields, their children’s schools. During the war, I walked among them. I sang with them. If they wept, I wept too. I never ruled from a tower—I ruled from the soil. That is what gives leadership its moral root. Not just order, but oneness.
Kim Jong Un:
Leadership today must balance memory and momentum. If I cling only to the past, we become a museum. If I abandon it, I become a traitor to my blood. I walk between two Koreas—one imagined by my grandfather, and one demanded by the 21st century. True leadership now? It’s about courage to change without losing face.
Rev. Moon (placing his hand on his heart):
I have long taught that God is not a dictator, but a parent. He does not rule with iron, but with tears. Let me ask the hardest question, then: What would you give up—for the sake of your people’s future?
Kim Il Sung:
I would give up the statues. The myths. The grand parades. If it meant my people could live without hunger, I would trade every monument for a full rice bowl. My name should live in hearts, not just in stone. But I say this to you, grandson—never mistake reverence for righteousness. Our people need faith in themselves, not just us.
Kim Jong Un:
I’ve already begun giving things up. Quietly. The control over certain markets. The way our youth dress, speak, dream. I watch it happen. I don’t stop it. That’s a form of surrender—and trust. I’d give up more. But not without purpose. Not just to be liked. I want change that honors legacy, not erases it.
Kim Jong Il:
I was not built for giving up. I was built for holding on. But even I know—if you clench too hard, things break. If I could return, I would soften the walls. A little. Let the sunlight in through cracks. Not enough to shake the structure. Just enough to let them breathe.
Rev. Moon (with a fatherly warmth):
Your words echo not just through this chamber, but across time. The people—your people—have suffered, but they have also endured. They do not only want food. They want meaning. Rule is not just about security. It is about raising children of God, not prisoners of fear.
He pauses, looking at each man.
Rev. Moon (softly):
The final chapter of your dynasty has not yet been written. Power is a sacred trust, not a throne. Will you rise from rulers to redeemers?
Kim Il Sung:
Perhaps that is the final revolution.
Kim Jong Il:
Perhaps... redemption is survival.
Kim Jong Un:
Perhaps it’s not about how long I rule... but what I leave behind.
Rev. Moon (closing):
Then let your legacy not be carved in marble, but in lives. Let your names be remembered not for ruling alone—but for awakening.
Topic 2: Juche in the 21st Century — Must It Change?
Moderator: Rev. Sun Myung Moon
Rev. Moon (leaning forward with quiet conviction):
Juche was born as a cry for dignity. Self-reliance, sovereignty, pride—these are sacred values. But the world has shifted, and your people hunger for more than ideals. So I ask you: Can Juche remain unchanged in this new century, or must it evolve to survive?
Kim Jong Il:
Juche is not a slogan. It is the spine of our nation. When others begged for aid, we stood firm. When allies crumbled, we remained. Without Juche, we are a leaf in the wind. To change it is to risk erasing our core.
Kim Jong Un:
Father, with respect, that spine is calcifying. I walk among a new generation—one that downloads music, trades in markets, watches the world through screens. Juche must speak to them, or it will become relic, not reason. We must update its meaning. Let it mean resilience and adaptation.
Kim Il Sung:
Juche was never meant to be rigidity. It was a response—to imperialism, to dependency, to betrayal. I wrote it to free our minds. If it now shackles them, we must ask: are we protecting its soul or preserving its shell? The spirit of Juche is liberation—not stagnation.
Rev. Moon (nodding):
Then let us go deeper. What is the heart of Juche? If you strip away politics and pride, what remains?
Kim Jong Un:
At its core, Juche means belief in one’s own people. That we are not lesser. That we can chart our own course. But belief must bear fruit. If we believe in our people, we must trust them—to innovate, to create, to lead. Juche without freedom is hypocrisy.
Kim Jong Il:
Its heart is control. Not to suffocate, but to protect. I watched what openness did to others—Yugoslavia torn, Gorbachev disgraced, China dancing with devils. You say trust the people. I say: trust the system that guards them. A shepherd does not release the wolves.
Kim Il Sung:
The heart of Juche, as I first taught it, was subjectivity. That man is the master of his own destiny. Not a pawn of history, not a tool of capitalism. But I never said man must be alone. We can trade, learn, cooperate—without surrendering soul.
Rev. Moon (softly):
Then what would Juche 2.0 look like—not just in theory, but in the streets of Pyongyang, the schools, the markets? Can Juche allow openness?
Kim Jong Il:
Controlled openness. A valve, not a floodgate. Markets, yes—but regulated. Culture, yes—but curated. Let them taste freedom, but not drink it recklessly.
Kim Jong Un:
I see Juche as a tree. Its roots run deep, but the branches must stretch toward sunlight. We open slowly—not because we are weak, but because we are wise. A digital economy, limited private enterprise, cultural exchange… These are not betrayals. They are strategies.
Kim Il Sung:
Reverend Moon, I once dreamed of a Korea that led the East in thought and innovation. We built factories and railroads with our bare hands. But our children today need new tools—code, creativity, commerce. If Juche cannot grow with them, it will bury them.
Rev. Moon (placing a hand on his chest):
I have spoken with leaders around the world—some rich, some ruined. The ones who thrive uplift their people’s divine potential. So I ask now, with honesty: What scares you about changing Juche?
Kim Jong Un:
That the world will not honor us—but devour us. That reform will be seen as weakness. That our people, given a taste of freedom, may never stop hungering. But I also fear the opposite: that without change, they will abandon us in their hearts, even if they remain in our borders.
Kim Jong Il:
What scares me? Collapse. Once, a single rumor unraveled a decade of control. Reform is not strategy—it is surgery. And surgery can kill the patient. I feared betrayal from within more than bombs from without. That fear is not irrational. It is inherited.
Kim Il Sung:
I feared too. But I also hoped. I hoped that one day, Juche would mean not just standing alone—but standing tall, surrounded by friends, not threats. I hoped my grandson would not have to choose between obedience and evolution. Fear protects—but hope builds.
Rev. Moon (firmly, yet warmly):
Then hear this: the root of Juche—human dignity—aligns with Heaven’s will. But dignity requires growth, not repetition. Are you ready to be remembered not just as defenders—but as visionaries?
Kim Il Sung:
If I could rewrite the pages, I’d write more in ink than stone. I would tell our people: "Think. Create. Question. Lead." Juche is not a wall—it is a mirror.
Kim Jong Un:
I want to be remembered not as the last ruler of a frozen dream—but the first leader of its rebirth. Let Juche guide us still—but let it breathe. Let it breathe.
Kim Jong Il (after a pause):
Perhaps... Perhaps I held it too tightly. Perhaps the time has come to pass the flame, not the chains.
Rev. Moon (rising, looking at all three):
Then let Juche be not the name of a doctrine, but of a people. A people who rise by their own hand, not to isolate—but to inspire.
Topic 3: Economy and Prosperity — Can We Give the People More?
Moderator: Rev. Sun Myung Moon
Rev. Moon (voice full of both gravity and grace):
Brothers, I ask you now not as leaders of a regime, but as caretakers of a people. The question before you is simple, yet profound: Can the people of North Korea truly prosper under your current economic model—or must the foundation shift to give them more?
Kim Jong Un:
I’ve seen the black markets bloom like weeds. Not because I permitted them, but because the people demanded them. When official rations failed, they traded in alleys, in whispers. Over time, those whispers became the economy itself. I had a choice: crush it, or adapt. I chose to let it breathe—barely.
Kim Jong Il:
Letting it breathe is a dangerous luxury. I once watched a famine eat the spirit of the nation. Discipline collapsed. Trade turned into theft. Hunger made people question—even flee. We are not like other nations. If we open too quickly, we invite chaos. Order first. Then reform—if still needed.
Kim Il Sung:
I built this country with iron and resolve—but also rice and roads. You cannot govern a hungry man for long. He will bow in the square, then curse you at home. The people must eat. Not just survive, but live. That is what gives legitimacy—not slogans, not parades, but full stomachs and warm homes.
Rev. Moon (nodding solemnly):
Then let us clarify what we mean by prosperity. I ask each of you: What would a truly prosperous North Korea look like—not in propaganda, but in practice?
Kim Jong Il:
In practice? A state where no one is left behind. A nation where health care is free, housing guaranteed, loyalty rewarded. A disciplined people—not corrupted by greed, not fractured by class. Prosperity is not wealth—it’s stability. A country that does not collapse when winds shift.
Kim Jong Un:
In my eyes, prosperity is when a child can dream of becoming a scientist, a poet, or a chef—not just a soldier. It’s when a mother doesn’t have to bribe to get medicine. When young people build apps, not escape plans. I want factories humming, cities glowing, exports rising. But more than that—I want choice, even in small things. Ice cream flavors. Books. Hairstyles. That’s the prosperity people crave now.
Kim Il Sung:
To me, a prosperous Korea is one where neighbors trust one another, where fields are green, where teachers are respected more than soldiers. When I saw our land healed from war, I wept—not for power, but for peace. We must not fear a nation of joy. Joy is strength.
Rev. Moon (softly):
And what stands in the way of this joy? What must you be willing to change to unlock this prosperity?
Kim Jong Un:
The fear of losing control. That’s the root. For decades, control was our currency. But I’ve begun to loosen the grip—in whispers, in pilot zones. We allow small market reforms, trial trade projects. But every change risks our identity unraveling. It’s a tightrope.
Kim Il Sung:
It was always a tightrope. Even in my day, I bartered behind closed doors, dealt with both East and West, danced between ideology and necessity. The truth? Pragmatism fed more people than ideology ever did. If something no longer works, change it. Do not be loyal to methods—be loyal to results.
Kim Jong Il:
But the price of change can be betrayal. One businessman gains power, another spreads foreign ideas. Control splinters. And yet… I wonder. Did we lose more by clinging to scarcity than we would have by gambling on growth?
Rev. Moon (gently):
It is not betrayal to feed your people. The kingdom of God does not run on slogans—it runs on love, on responsibility. Let me ask you this: If you could sit with a young worker in Chongjin or a grandmother in Hyesan, what would you tell them about what’s to come?
Kim Il Sung:
I would tell them: “You have not been forgotten.” That your labor, your patience, your tears—are seen. That we will build a system that does not just demand, but returns. I would promise a future where a man’s sweat earns not suspicion, but comfort.
Kim Jong Un:
I would tell them: “You are allowed to hope again.” That we are laying tracks for trade. That local markets will have more goods. That education will not just be ideology, but technology. I cannot promise abundance yet—but I can promise effort. Serious, honest effort.
Kim Jong Il:
I would speak less and listen more. Maybe I didn’t do enough of that. If I could return, I would listen to the woman selling noodles in the alley, to the boy shining shoes near the station. They held the pulse I ignored. I would tell them: “We failed you in some ways—but we taught survival. Now, it’s time to build life.”
Rev. Moon (with glowing sincerity):
Then let your economy become your altar—not just of numbers, but of service. Every transaction, every policy, must bow to the dignity of your people. When you uplift the least of them, you uplift Heaven.
He pauses.
Rev. Moon:
You ask, “Can we give the people more?” The better question is: Can you become more—so that your people may, too?
Kim Il Sung (smiling faintly):
Then let the revolution begin again—but this time, in the hearts, not the guns.
Kim Jong Il:
Let control evolve into care. Let fear become foresight.
Kim Jong Un:
Let our legacy be not just missiles and medals—but milk, music, and meaning.
Rev. Moon (concluding):
Then go forward—not as rulers, but as restorers. Let prosperity not be a promise, but a practice. And let your nation rise—not as an island, but as a light.
Topic 4: The Question of Peace — Can We Ever Stop the War?
Moderator: Rev. Sun Myung Moon
Rev. Moon (with a gaze that pierces time):
My brothers, the Korean War never truly ended. The peninsula breathes, but it does not rest. Armistice is not peace—it is pause. I ask each of you now, from the depths of your soul: Can we ever stop this war? And if so, what would real peace look like for our people?
Kim Il Sung:
Peace. I sought it more than I ever admitted. I watched cities burn, mothers flee, children starve—on both sides. Yet peace could never come at the cost of submission. I signed the armistice with a heavy pen. Not with satisfaction, but necessity. If we are to end the war, it must be peace with dignity. Not a victor and vanquished—but equals.
Kim Jong Un:
Peace is no longer about guns. It’s about relevance. A starving country at peace is still a prisoner. My people want to travel, trade, dream. I do not seek unconditional peace—I seek peace with terms that protect our identity. A peace that opens doors without breaking the frame.
Kim Jong Il:
Peace is a chessboard. It was never about the Korean people alone—it was about the U.S., China, Russia, South Korea. We were a pawn in larger games. I pursued nuclear arms not because I loved weapons, but because I needed leverage. Without deterrence, we were voiceless. Peace can only come when we are no longer treated as prey.
Rev. Moon (with firm compassion):
And yet, each of you wielded war as if it were the only path. Tell me now—what have been the true costs of keeping the war alive for 70 years?
Kim Jong Il:
We built walls—around minds, not just borders. We lost generations to paranoia. Children taught to hate before they could read. The army consumed the harvest. Songs became slogans. Yes, we endured—but what kind of life did we protect?
Kim Il Sung:
The cost was not just material—it was spiritual. I saw reunions denied, letters never written, graves never visited. Peace never came, and so healing never began. We raised our people in defiance, but also in loneliness. That grief echoes louder than artillery.
Kim Jong Un:
I feel it every day. Youths drifting from ideology, elders from faith. They don’t ask why we hate the South—they ask why they can’t text their cousins there. Why they can’t see what life could be. The war gave us legitimacy once. Now, it steals our future.
Rev. Moon (pausing, then softly):
You have all named the wounds. But what is the remedy? What would it take—truly—for you to lay down the war once and for all?
Kim Jong Un:
Trust. But trust cannot be demanded. It must be built. We need reciprocal steps—economic agreements, cultural exchanges, symbolic gestures. A peace park at the DMZ. An Olympic team united. A single train route from Busan to Pyongyang. Peace starts with presence.
Kim Jong Il:
What would it take? Guarantees. From America. From Seoul. Not just words, but actions. End the military drills. Sign a real treaty. Let embassies rise. Then, maybe, we can lower our guard. Until then, suspicion is our currency.
Kim Il Sung:
Peace begins with forgiveness. Hard, public, painful forgiveness. I would travel to Seoul, if I could again. Not to negotiate, but to mourn. With the mothers of the South and the North. Let us build monuments not to soldiers—but to sons lost. When grief is shared, peace can grow.
Rev. Moon (quietly):
What about reunification? Is that still a dream—or a delusion?
Kim Il Sung:
It is a dream—but no longer as I once imagined. Not absorption. Not domination. But two systems learning to breathe side by side. A confederation, perhaps. A slow dance, not a forced embrace.
Kim Jong Un:
I speak of it carefully now. My people fear being swallowed by capitalism. The South fears being dragged into poverty. But what if we started with culture, education, sports? Let students exchange. Let art cross the border. That is how the walls come down—one story, one song at a time.
Kim Jong Il:
Reunification as ideology is dead. Reunification as coexistence—that has potential. But only if both sides abandon pride as policy.
Rev. Moon (rising):
Then I ask you, as a father asks his sons: What legacy do you want to leave? A frozen line—or a healed land?
Kim Jong Il (after a long pause):
I wanted to be remembered as the one who preserved. But I now see that preservation without transformation is suffocation. I would accept peace, even if it meant the world remembered me differently.
Kim Jong Un:
I want my name tied not to missiles—but to music. To bridges. To treaties signed under cherry blossoms. I want my people to smile without fear. I want to lead them to light, not lock them in tunnels.
Kim Il Sung:
Let my statues crumble, if it means the border can fall. Let history judge me harshly, if it means children on both sides laugh together again.
Rev. Moon (with steady conviction):
Then let this be your truce—not of weapons, but of wills. The war was inherited—but peace must be chosen. Let the North and South become the two lungs of one soul. Not the same—but breathing together.
Topic 5: Legacy and the Future — What Will Our Name Mean?
Moderator: Rev. Sun Myung Moon
Rev. Moon (standing quietly under a symbolic pine tree):
Legacy is the final test of leadership. It is not written in monuments but in memory—etched into the hearts of your people and the conscience of history. So I ask each of you now: What do you believe your legacy is today? And what do you want it to become?
Kim Jong Il:
My legacy? I know what the world says. That I ruled in shadows, that I fed fear and missiles while my people starved. But they don’t know the fires I walked through—how close we came to vanishing. I kept the structure standing, when everyone expected it to collapse. My legacy may be harsh—but I ruled to preserve. Perhaps I was a wall. Let others be doors.
Kim Jong Un:
My legacy isn’t written yet. But I fear that if I do nothing, I’ll be remembered as the final act of a fading play. That terrifies me. I want to be remembered not as a ruler of fear, but as a leader who opened the sky. A man who took a hard inheritance and chose a softer future.
Kim Il Sung:
I am remembered by many as the founder, the liberator, the eternal president. And yet... I look now and wonder: Did I build a house of iron, but forget the windows? I want my name to mean hope, not just history. Not just survival—but strength born of love for the people. If my grandchildren can turn our name into a bridge, not a bunker, then I will rest in peace.
Rev. Moon (softly):
You’ve each ruled with fire—but the next generation needs light. So tell me now: What does your family name—Kim—owe to the future of Korea?
Kim Jong Un:
It owes freedom from fear. Our name has become both shield and sword. But now it must become something else—a shelter. I owe the people the right to dream without being watched. The right to disagree and still be safe. If the name Kim is to survive, it must evolve.
Kim Il Sung:
The name Kim was never meant to be divine. We let statues rise too high. We forgot that leaders must walk with the people—not stand above them. What we owe is humility. And correction. It is not betrayal to change—it is devotion.
Kim Jong Il:
We owe honesty. And perhaps even apology. Not in weakness, but in wisdom. If my name stings in some mouths, I accept that. But let it also be remembered as the name that endured long enough to learn.
Rev. Moon (now more urgent, almost fatherly):
But name alone is not enough. What action—one bold step—would you take to shape your legacy while you still can?
Kim Il Sung:
I would tear down the wall at Panmunjom—not all at once, but piece by piece. I would let children from the North and South play together. Let grandparents see lost families. I would do this not as surrender, but as strength. That is how our name could mean healing.
Kim Jong Un:
I would invite world leaders to Pyongyang—not for defense talks, but for culture. An international arts summit. A peace concert in Kim Il Sung Square. I would fund science, education, food—not weapons. And most of all, I would speak to my people without a script.
Kim Jong Il:
I would declassify the truth. Let the archives speak. Let the ghosts be known. If legacy is to be earned, not imposed, the people must see us clearly. Warts and all. I would give them that. Transparency as redemption.
Rev. Moon (with profound stillness):
You have spoken of what you want to leave behind. Now let me ask you what few dare to ask: When you meet your ancestors—or your Creator—what do you hope they say about your rule?
Kim Jong Il:
That I did not flinch. That I kept the structure intact long enough for someone else to soften it. That I bore the cold so that another could light a fire.
Kim Jong Un:
That I saw the signs of change and did not hide from them. That I chose bridges over borders. That I gave the next generation a new map. And that, in the end, I loved my people more than I feared the world.
Kim Il Sung:
That I built something lasting. That I lifted my people from ashes and gave them pride. But most of all—that I passed on not just a country, but a conscience. That the name Kim no longer meant command, but compassion.
Rev. Moon (with deep finality):
Then let it be written not just in books, but in hearts: the Kim legacy was reborn in courage, in humility, and in love. Let it not be a chapter closed in blood, but a door opened in trust. Power ends. But legacy? That lives in the way your people sing, laugh, and dream long after you are gone.
He looks to the heavens, and then to them.
Rev. Moon (concluding):
You were rulers. Now be ancestors. May your name no longer cast a shadow, but become a sunrise.
Final Thoughts by Rev. Sun Myung Moon
Now the conversation draws to a close—not with answers written in stone, but with hearts cracked open.
I have sat with three men who have ruled through famine and force, through myth and memory. And yet, beneath the uniforms and ideologies, I saw something deeper: not tyrants, but sons. Sons of Korea. Sons of history. Sons, still capable of change.
Kim Il Sung, you built with strength. Kim Jong Il, you endured with strategy. Kim Jong Un, you now stand at a turning point, where fear and hope war quietly in your soul. And I tell you this—not as a critic, but as a father: the greatest revolution is not fought on battlefields. It is fought in the human heart.
There is no shame in shifting. There is no weakness in softening. To bring your people more food than slogans, more joy than parades, more freedom than fear—that is a legacy far greater than statues. Let the age of punishment end. Let the age of healing begin.
If you choose peace, if you choose humility, if you choose to love your people more than your image—then history will not forget you. It will forgive you. And it will thank you.
And when you meet your ancestors, and the Creator, you will not need to defend your rule. You will only need to say: “I tried to end the suffering. I tried to begin something new.”
To the world, I say this: do not close your ears to North Korea. Do not lock her in her past. She is not only the shadow of war, but the soil of a new dawn.
To the people of Korea—North and South—I say: The time for reunion is not a fantasy. It is a promise waiting to be fulfilled.
Let this be the moment we remember.
The moment when the war began to end.
Not with weapons.
But with words.
And perhaps, in time, with love.
Short Bios:
Leave a Reply