Haruki Murakami & Great Writers Discuss Alienation and Meaning

I want to take a moment to invite you into a truly unforgettable imaginary conversation—one that brings together some of the most influential literary minds ever to walk this earth. Now, I know this might sound a little unusual, but that’s because it is. In this imagined conversation, we’re joined by none other than Haruki Murakami, F. Scott Fitzgerald, Raymond Chandler, Franz Kafka, Fyodor Dostoevsky, and J.D. Salinger.

These writers have captured our hearts and minds through their stories about alienation, morality, dreams, and the search for meaning. But today, we’re pulling back the curtain, bringing these brilliant thinkers together to dive deep into the themes that have shaped their timeless works.

They’ll discuss topics that are just as relevant today as they were when they first penned their iconic stories—alienation in the modern world, what it means to search for meaning, the blurred lines between dreams and reality, and how each of us, in our own way, is an outsider trying to find our place.

So, whether you’re a longtime fan of these authors or new to their works, this conversation will resonate with you. It's an exploration of the human condition that will leave you thinking, reflecting, and, hopefully, discovering something new about yourself and the world around you. Let’s join them now.

The Alienation of the Modern Individual

Nick Sasaki: Welcome, everyone. Today, we’re diving into a central theme that runs through all of your works: the alienation of the modern individual. How do your characters reflect the sense of isolation that many people feel, even in the midst of a rapidly changing society? Haruki, let’s start with you.

Haruki Murakami: Thank you, Nick. In much of my writing, particularly in novels like Kafka on the Shore and Norwegian Wood, alienation is something my characters experience profoundly. They often feel a deep disconnect not only from the people around them but also from their own inner selves. Modern life, in my view, exacerbates this sense of isolation. We’re more connected than ever, but that connection is often superficial. My characters wander through surreal, sometimes metaphysical spaces as a way to reflect their internal worlds—worlds that are confused, detached, and seeking meaning. I think this resonates because, in today’s society, we all feel fragmented in one way or another, torn between different realities and expectations.

Nick Sasaki: That sense of wandering through multiple realities is powerful. Your characters often seem like they’re living in parallel worlds, both literally and metaphorically. Scott, in The Great Gatsby, Gatsby seems to live in a world of his own creation, disconnected from the reality around him. How do you view his alienation?

F. Scott Fitzgerald: Gatsby’s alienation is self-imposed, in a way. He has constructed this dream around Daisy, this vision of a perfect life that doesn’t really exist. He isolates himself in pursuit of that dream, and in doing so, he becomes disconnected from everyone around him, including Daisy herself. He throws these grand parties but remains distant, almost ghost-like in his own home. Gatsby’s alienation is a byproduct of chasing a dream that’s rooted in the past. The more he tries to reach it, the more isolated he becomes. For me, that represents the hollow pursuit of the American Dream, where even success and wealth can’t fill the emptiness that alienation creates.

Nick Sasaki: Gatsby’s isolation in the midst of opulence is indeed a striking contrast. Raymond, Marlowe operates in a gritty, realistic world, yet he’s also an outsider. How does his sense of alienation shape his character?

Raymond Chandler: Marlowe’s alienation is both a product of his world and his own making. He chooses to stand apart from the corruption around him, which isolates him from the people he deals with—criminals, police, and clients alike. He’s in the world, but not of it. His moral code keeps him isolated because he refuses to compromise, even though it would be easier to blend in. In a way, his alienation gives him clarity—he’s able to see the world for what it really is because he’s not entangled in its web. But that also makes him a lonely figure, someone who walks the streets alone because he can’t connect with a world he doesn’t respect.

Nick Sasaki: Marlowe’s self-imposed isolation seems to protect him but also deepens his loneliness. Franz, in The Castle, K. is perpetually alienated from both society and the authority he seeks. How do you explore alienation in your work?

Franz Kafka: K.’s alienation is existential. He arrives in the village, seeking recognition and a place within the bureaucratic system of the Castle, but he never achieves either. The world he encounters is absurd and indifferent to his existence. No matter how hard he tries, he remains disconnected—not only from the people around him but from any sense of purpose. His alienation is not just social but also metaphysical. He’s isolated from any clear meaning or understanding of the world he’s in. In many ways, this mirrors the modern condition—people seeking structure and meaning in systems that are often indifferent to their struggles.

Nick Sasaki: That existential isolation really captures the disconnection many feel today. J.D., your iconic character Holden Caulfield in The Catcher in the Rye embodies a sense of alienation that feels timeless. How does Holden’s alienation reflect the modern individual’s experience?

J.D. Salinger: Holden’s alienation comes from his deep disillusionment with the world around him. He feels that everyone is phony, that society is filled with people who don’t really understand him. His rejection of the adult world—its hypocrisies, its expectations—leaves him isolated. He longs for something pure, like the innocence of childhood, but he can’t find it anywhere. Holden’s alienation is both a rebellion and a cry for help. He’s searching for connection, but the more he looks, the more disconnected he becomes. I think that reflects the alienation many young people feel, especially in a society that pressures them to conform to roles they don’t want to play.

Nick Sasaki: Holden’s alienation speaks to a deep yearning for authenticity in a world that often feels false. Fyodor, your characters in The Brothers Karamazov, particularly Ivan, also experience a deep sense of alienation. How do you approach this theme?

Fyodor Dostoevsky: For Ivan Karamazov, alienation stems from his intellectual and moral rebellion. He rejects the world as it is, and by doing so, isolates himself from faith, family, and society. His alienation is philosophical—he cannot reconcile the suffering he sees with the idea of a just God, and this moral dilemma distances him from the people around him. His brother, Alyosha, is the opposite—his connection to faith brings him closer to others. In my view, alienation is the result of spiritual or philosophical disconnection. The more Ivan doubts, the more isolated he becomes. Alienation, in this sense, is not just an emotional state but a consequence of rejecting the foundations that bind people together—faith, love, and meaning.

Nick Sasaki: It’s fascinating how alienation, whether self-imposed, existential, or philosophical, emerges in each of your works. Each of your characters seems to grapple with this sense of disconnection in different ways, reflecting the modern individual’s struggle to find connection in a fragmented world. Let’s carry these ideas forward as we move on to our next topic.

Morality and the Human Condition

Nick Sasaki: Our next topic is morality and the human condition. Each of you has explored profound moral questions through your characters, often in very different ways. How do you see morality shaping the human experience? Haruki, why don’t we start with you?

Haruki Murakami: Morality in my stories exists in shades of gray. My characters often find themselves in morally ambiguous situations, where right and wrong aren’t clearly defined. For example, in 1Q84 or Kafka on the Shore, they’re forced to make decisions without clear moral guidelines, which reflects modern life, where we’re constantly bombarded with conflicting values and expectations. Morality is fluid, and individuals must navigate their own path, often in isolation, to determine what is right for them. That search for personal morality, amid societal and existential confusion, is central to many of my works.

Nick Sasaki: That moral ambiguity is something that definitely resonates in the complexities of modern life. Scott, your characters, especially Gatsby, seem to be morally compromised by their pursuit of wealth and status. How do you see morality in The Great Gatsby?

F. Scott Fitzgerald: In The Great Gatsby, morality is tied to the hollow pursuit of the American Dream. Gatsby builds his entire life around the idea of winning back Daisy, but to do so, he engages in illegal activities, deceives others, and ultimately loses touch with his own identity. The moral compromise Gatsby makes in his pursuit of the dream reflects a society where wealth and power overshadow integrity and human connection. I wanted to show how the moral decay of the Roaring Twenties wasn’t just about the excesses of wealth, but about the way people compromised their values for personal gain.

Nick Sasaki: Gatsby’s moral decay is a powerful reflection of that time. Raymond, Marlowe’s morality seems very personal, almost a code he lives by in a corrupt world. What drives his moral decisions?

Raymond Chandler: Marlowe’s moral code is what sets him apart. In a world full of corruption, deceit, and violence, he’s the rare character who tries to hold on to his principles. He operates in the gray areas, dealing with criminals and compromised people, but he has a clear sense of right and wrong—at least by his own standards. His morality isn’t about following the law or societal norms; it’s about personal integrity. He’s willing to take risks and make enemies to do what he believes is right. For Marlowe, morality is something you live by, even when no one’s watching.

Nick Sasaki: That internal sense of morality is what makes Marlowe so compelling. Franz, in The Castle, K. is constantly seeking approval and validation from an indifferent system. Does morality play a role in his quest?

Franz Kafka: K. is not so much seeking moral guidance as he is seeking recognition and understanding from a system that offers none. His quest is a reflection of the modern condition, where individuals search for meaning in a world that often seems arbitrary and indifferent. Morality, in my work, is elusive—it exists, but it’s hidden beneath layers of bureaucracy and existential confusion. K.’s journey is not a moral one in the traditional sense, but rather a struggle to understand a world where morality is unclear, where the system he confronts doesn’t provide any clear answers. It’s a reflection of how modern individuals often face institutions and social structures that are indifferent to their personal struggles for meaning and justice. Morality in The Castle is less about right or wrong and more about the futility of seeking validation in a fragmented world.

Nick Sasaki: That lack of clear moral structure definitely adds to the sense of alienation your characters experience. J.D., in The Catcher in the Rye, Holden’s moral struggle seems to stem from his disillusionment with the world around him. How do you see morality shaping his journey?

J.D. Salinger: Holden’s struggle is deeply tied to his moral vision of the world. He sees the adult world as corrupt and "phony," filled with people who have lost their sense of innocence and integrity. His desire to be the "catcher in the rye," saving children from falling into the corruption of adulthood, is a moral ideal he clings to. But it’s a hopeless quest—one that alienates him even more. Holden’s morality is purer, more idealistic, but it also isolates him because he’s unable to reconcile it with the complex, morally ambiguous world he’s forced to live in. His alienation is not just social, it’s also moral—he feels like the only one who still cares about what’s right.

Nick Sasaki: Holden’s quest for purity and integrity in a "phony" world is certainly a unique take on morality. Fyodor, your characters in The Brothers Karamazov, particularly Ivan, wrestle deeply with moral questions about good and evil, faith and doubt. How does morality define their lives?

Fyodor Dostoevsky: Morality in The Brothers Karamazov is at the very core of the characters’ struggles. Ivan’s rejection of God and the moral order represents the intellectual rebellion against traditional values. He cannot accept a world in which innocent suffering exists, and this drives him into isolation and despair. His brother, Alyosha, represents the opposite—he finds meaning and morality through his faith and his love for others. The tension between these two worldviews—rational doubt and spiritual faith—is what drives the moral conflict in the novel. For Ivan, morality without God is a source of torment, while for Alyosha, morality is found in connection with the divine and in acts of love and kindness toward others.

Nick Sasaki: It’s fascinating how morality, whether intellectual, spiritual, or personal, plays such a central role in shaping your characters’ paths. Across all of your works, morality is not a fixed concept—it’s something that each individual must grapple with in their own way. Let’s move forward and explore the theme of dreams and reality.

Dreams and Reality: Blurring the Lines

Nick Sasaki: Today’s topic explores the fascinating intersection between dreams and reality, which is central to many of your works. Whether it’s the surreal landscapes in Kafka’s world or the elusive dream Gatsby chases, each of you has used dreams to reflect something about human existence. Haruki, your works are often described as dream-like. How do you use dreams and alternate realities to explore the human experience?

Haruki Murakami: Dreams in my work are often an extension of reality, a parallel world where the subconscious has a voice. In novels like The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle and 1Q84, the boundaries between dreams and reality blur because I believe that our internal lives—the things we think and feel but don’t express—are just as real as the physical world we navigate. Dreams allow my characters to confront hidden parts of themselves or to explore emotional truths that they can’t face in the waking world. I think dreams help us make sense of the chaos around us, to find meaning in a world that often feels fragmented or surreal.

Nick Sasaki: That idea of dreams as a space to confront emotional truths is powerful. Scott, in The Great Gatsby, the American Dream feels almost like an illusion—something Gatsby is chasing but can never quite reach. How does the theme of dreams play out in your work?

F. Scott Fitzgerald: The American Dream in The Great Gatsby is more of a mirage than a dream. Gatsby’s entire life is built around the idea of recreating the past, of winning Daisy’s love and achieving a level of wealth and status that will finally make him happy. But that dream is unattainable—it’s an illusion. Gatsby is chasing something that doesn’t exist, and in the process, he loses sight of reality. The green light at the end of Daisy’s dock symbolizes that dream—always visible, but always out of reach. In this way, dreams in The Great Gatsby represent the desires that drive us, but also the illusions that can destroy us.

Nick Sasaki: That unattainable dream really resonates with the theme of illusion versus reality. Raymond, Marlowe exists in a very gritty, realistic world, but he also seems to live by a kind of personal dream, an ideal of justice that’s often out of step with the world around him. How do you see dreams playing out in your work?

Raymond Chandler: Marlowe’s dream, if you want to call it that, is a vision of justice that he holds onto despite the corruption around him. He’s chasing a kind of moral ideal that doesn’t really exist in the world he lives in, but he can’t let go of it. In a way, his sense of justice is like Gatsby’s green light—it’s something that gives him purpose, but it also isolates him. Marlowe knows the world isn’t going to change, but he can’t stop himself from trying to hold onto his personal code. The dream isn’t about success or wealth; it’s about integrity, and that’s what keeps him going, even if he’s the last man standing.

Nick Sasaki: Marlowe’s personal code as a kind of dream is a fascinating take. Franz, in The Castle, the world itself feels like a dream—absurd, disconnected from logic. How do you approach the blending of dreams and reality in your work?

Franz Kafka: In The Castle, reality itself feels like a nightmare. K.’s quest to gain entry to the Castle and to understand the system reflects how people search for meaning in a world that offers none. The bureaucracy, the absurdity, the lack of clear answers—these elements make the world feel dream-like, but not in a positive sense. It’s more of a suffocating dream, one where you’re constantly seeking something just out of reach, much like Gatsby’s green light. The difference is, in my work, there’s no hope of ever reaching that goal. The dream becomes a reflection of the frustration and confusion of modern life.

Nick Sasaki: That sense of perpetual frustration and inaccessibility is something many readers can relate to. J.D., in The Catcher in the Rye, Holden seems to be searching for a kind of idealized world that doesn’t exist, much like a dream. How does the theme of dreams versus reality play out in his journey?

J.D. Salinger: Holden’s dream is one of innocence—he wants to preserve the purity of childhood, to save kids from falling into the corrupt adult world. In his mind, adulthood is this nightmare where people lose their integrity and become "phonies." His dream is to be the catcher in the rye, standing at the edge of a cliff, preventing children from falling into that world. But, like Gatsby’s dream, it’s unattainable. Holden’s journey is about coming to terms with the fact that you can’t hold onto innocence forever, and that dream of protecting it is impossible. The reality is, you have to grow up, but Holden’s struggle is that he can’t accept that reality.

Nick Sasaki: Holden’s dream of protecting innocence really highlights the tension between holding onto ideals and accepting the inevitability of change. Fyodor, your characters in The Brothers Karamazov grapple with dreams and reality in a more philosophical or religious sense. How do dreams play into their search for meaning?

Fyodor Dostoevsky: Dreams in The Brothers Karamazov often reveal deeper spiritual or moral truths. Ivan’s dream of the Devil, for instance, is a reflection of his inner torment and his rejection of God. In that dream, he’s confronted with his doubts, his fears, and his inability to reconcile the suffering in the world with a just and loving God. For me, dreams are a way for characters to confront the parts of themselves they hide from in the waking world. The dream is not separate from reality—it’s an extension of it, a place where characters face the spiritual and moral struggles they carry with them. Dreams in my work are windows into the soul.

Nick Sasaki: Across your works, dreams serve as powerful reflections of the internal struggles your characters face. Whether it’s the pursuit of an unattainable ideal or a confrontation with deeper moral and spiritual truths, dreams blur the lines between reality and imagination. Let’s explore these ideas further in our next topic.

The Search for Meaning in a Fragmented World

Nick Sasaki: Our next topic: the search for meaning in a fragmented world. Each of your works explores how individuals try to make sense of a chaotic or disconnected reality. Haruki, in your novels, characters often embark on journeys to understand their place in the world, particularly in fragmented, surreal landscapes. How does the search for meaning play out in your work?

Haruki Murakami: In my stories, the search for meaning is deeply personal. My characters often feel a sense of disconnection from the world around them, and their journeys are as much about discovering their own inner landscapes as they are about interacting with the external world. For example, in The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle and Kafka on the Shore, the characters grapple with fragmented realities—both literal and metaphorical. They dive into parallel worlds or dream-like states to search for answers, and while they might not always find a clear solution, the journey itself is the process of creating meaning. In our modern, fragmented world, meaning isn’t something that’s given—it’s something we have to actively seek out or even create for ourselves.

Nick Sasaki: That sense of creating one’s own meaning in a chaotic world resonates deeply. Scott, in The Great Gatsby, Gatsby is also searching for meaning, but it seems to come in the form of an elusive dream. How do you see the search for meaning in his story?

F. Scott Fitzgerald: Gatsby’s search for meaning is tied to his vision of the American Dream, but it’s a fragmented and ultimately unattainable one. He believes that by achieving wealth and status, he can reclaim a lost love and, in doing so, find happiness and fulfillment. But the tragedy is that this dream is built on an illusion—he’s trying to recreate the past, to capture something that’s already gone. The search for meaning, in Gatsby’s case, becomes a destructive obsession. He’s chasing an ideal that’s fragmented, just like the society he’s living in. In the end, the dream collapses, and Gatsby’s life is revealed to be hollow, a reflection of a world that often offers empty promises.

Nick Sasaki: Gatsby’s search for meaning through wealth and status speaks to the broader societal fragmentation of his time—and even today. Raymond, Marlowe operates in a morally compromised world, yet he seems to have his own idea of what meaning looks like. How does Marlowe search for meaning in a fragmented world?

Raymond Chandler: Marlowe is a man living in a broken world, but he’s someone who creates his own meaning by sticking to a personal code. The world around him is full of corruption, violence, and betrayal, but Marlowe finds meaning by holding on to his sense of justice and integrity. He’s a loner, an outsider, but that’s where his strength lies. In a world that’s chaotic and fragmented, where most people are willing to compromise their values for survival, Marlowe stays true to his principles. His search for meaning isn’t about finding answers in society or in some grand ideal—it’s about living according to his own sense of right and wrong, even if it isolates him from others.

Nick Sasaki: Marlowe’s personal code gives him a sense of stability in an otherwise unstable world. Franz, in The Castle, your character K. is constantly searching for meaning within a bureaucratic system that seems indifferent to him. How does this reflect the search for meaning in your work?

Franz Kafka: K.’s search for meaning is ultimately futile because he’s trying to find purpose in a system that is opaque, indifferent, and ultimately meaningless. The Castle represents an unknowable, unreachable authority, much like modern institutions that people turn to for validation or understanding. K.’s frustration reflects the broader human condition—the desire to find meaning in a world that offers little in return. In many ways, this reflects the absurdity of life. We search for meaning in systems, whether political, social, or religious, that often don’t provide the answers we’re looking for. K.’s journey is not about finding meaning but about grappling with the impossibility of ever truly understanding the forces that control our lives.

Nick Sasaki: That existential struggle resonates with the experience of searching for meaning in a seemingly indifferent world. J.D., Holden Caulfield in The Catcher in the Rye is also searching for meaning, but he’s disillusioned with the world around him. How does Holden’s search for meaning shape his character?

J.D. Salinger: Holden is searching for meaning in a world he perceives as false and hypocritical. He’s deeply disillusioned with the adult world, which he feels is full of "phonies." His search for meaning takes the form of a longing for innocence, which he associates with childhood. The problem is, Holden can’t stop the world from changing—he can’t protect himself or others from the inevitability of growing up. His journey is a desperate attempt to find something real, something pure, in a world that seems broken to him. But the more he searches, the more he realizes that innocence can’t be preserved, and the harder it becomes for him to find any sense of belonging or purpose. Holden’s search for meaning is a battle between holding onto ideals and facing the complexities of reality.

Nick Sasaki: Holden’s battle with the loss of innocence highlights the difficulty of finding meaning when the world around you feels disconnected from your values. Fyodor, your characters in The Brothers Karamazov often confront deeply philosophical questions about life, suffering, and faith. How do they search for meaning in a fragmented world?

Fyodor Dostoevsky: In The Brothers Karamazov, each character represents a different path in the search for meaning. Ivan grapples with the intellectual problem of evil and suffering, which drives him to reject God and, by extension, the traditional structures of meaning. Alyosha, on the other hand, finds meaning through his faith and his connection to others—through love, community, and the spiritual acceptance of suffering. For Dmitri, the search for meaning comes through his experiences with guilt and redemption. The world they live in is fragmented by doubt, suffering, and the collapse of traditional values, but each character is searching for something deeper. I believe meaning can still be found, even in a fragmented world, through faith, love, and the ability to endure suffering. It is a difficult path, but it’s one that offers redemption.

Nick Sasaki: It’s interesting to see how, across all your works, meaning is not something easily attained, but something your characters must struggle to find or create for themselves. Let’s move on to our final topic, where we’ll explore the role of the outsider in society.

The Role of the Outsider in Society

Nick Sasaki: Our last topic: the role of the outsider in society. Each of your characters exists on the fringes, challenging or reflecting societal norms. What does it mean to be an outsider in your stories, and how does that shape the human experience? Haruki, you often write about characters who exist outside of mainstream society. How do you see the role of the outsider in your work?

Haruki Murakami: In my work, the outsider is often someone who has chosen or been forced into a position of isolation, but that isolation allows them to see the world from a different perspective. Characters like Toru in The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle or Kafka in Kafka on the Shore don’t fit into the normal structures of society, and that gives them a kind of freedom. They’re not bound by societal expectations, which allows them to embark on journeys of self-discovery. But at the same time, being an outsider can be lonely. It’s a double-edged sword. You gain a unique perspective, but you also lose a sense of connection to others. The outsider is often a vehicle for exploring themes of identity, isolation, and personal freedom.

Nick Sasaki: The outsider as a vehicle for personal freedom is a compelling idea. Scott, Gatsby is both an insider and an outsider in the world of wealth and privilege. How do you see his role as an outsider in The Great Gatsby?

F. Scott Fitzgerald: Gatsby is an outsider pretending to be an insider. He’s built this persona of wealth and success, but deep down, he’s still James Gatz, a boy from North Dakota who doesn’t really belong in the world of East Egg. He’s constantly striving to be accepted by a society that will never fully embrace him. His outsider status defines his tragedy—no matter how much wealth he accumulates or how lavish his parties are, he’ll always be on the outside looking in. Gatsby’s role as an outsider reflects the hollowness of the American Dream, where even those who achieve the dream find themselves isolated and disconnected from the very people they’re trying to impress.

Nick Sasaki: Gatsby’s outsider status speaks to the illusion of belonging in a world driven by wealth and status. Raymond, Marlowe operates outside the law, yet he has his own moral code. How does being an outsider define him?

Raymond Chandler: Marlowe is an outsider by choice. He’s not part of the corruption that surrounds him, and that’s what keeps him isolated. He works with criminals, law enforcement, and high society, but he doesn’t belong to any of those worlds. Marlowe’s role as an outsider gives him a certain moral clarity—he’s able to see the flaws in the systems around him because he’s not tied to them. But that also makes him a lonely figure. He walks the streets alone because he can’t fit into the world he’s trying to clean up. His strength comes from being an outsider, but it also comes with a price.

Nick Sasaki: That sense of isolation gives Marlowe a unique strength, but also a heavy burden. Franz, your characters, especially in The Castle, are often outsiders who struggle to find their place in a world that seems indifferent to them. How does the role of the outsider function in your work?

Franz Kafka: In The Castle, K. is the ultimate outsider. He arrives in a village that he doesn’t understand, where the rules are opaque, and he’s constantly trying to gain access to a system that remains inaccessible. His outsider status is both a social and existential one. He’s not just an outsider in the village; he’s an outsider in life, searching for meaning and recognition in a world that refuses to give it to him. The outsider in my work represents the individual’s struggle against incomprehensible systems of power and control. Being an outsider is a state of perpetual frustration and isolation, but it also reflects the broader human condition—our constant search for understanding in a world that remains largely indifferent.

Nick Sasaki: That perpetual frustration is something many can relate to, especially when it comes to navigating systems that seem impenetrable. J.D., Holden Caulfield is also an outsider, but his alienation seems to be more personal and emotional. How does being an outsider shape Holden’s experience in The Catcher in the Rye?

J.D. Salinger: Holden is very much an emotional and social outsider. He doesn’t fit into the adult world he finds so phony, and he doesn’t feel comfortable with the expectations placed on him by society. His outsider status is a form of rebellion—he rejects the values and norms of the adult world because he sees them as corrupt. But at the same time, being an outsider is a source of deep loneliness for Holden. He’s searching for connection, but the more he rejects society, the more isolated he becomes. His role as an outsider is central to his struggle to hold onto his innocence while grappling with the inevitability of growing up. For Holden, being an outsider is both a defense mechanism and a source of pain.

Nick Sasaki: Holden’s emotional isolation really captures the tension between wanting to belong and rejecting the world around him. Fyodor, in The Brothers Karamazov, your characters also experience a form of outsider status, particularly Ivan. How does this shape their journeys?

Fyodor Dostoevsky: Ivan Karamazov is an intellectual and spiritual outsider. His rejection of God and his questioning of the moral order set him apart from those around him, especially from his brother Alyosha, who represents faith and connection. Ivan’s outsider status comes from his inability to reconcile the suffering he sees in the world with a belief in a just and loving God. This makes him not just an outsider to society, but to his own family and to the spiritual world. His isolation leads him to a deep philosophical despair, which in turn alienates him even more. In my work, the outsider is often someone who questions the foundations of society, whether it’s moral, intellectual, or spiritual. This questioning leads to isolation, but it’s also part of the search for truth.

Nick Sasaki: It’s interesting to see how, across all your works, the outsider plays a crucial role in challenging societal norms, whether through intellectual, emotional, or existential rebellion. The outsider, while often isolated, also serves as a mirror to the flaws and contradictions of society itself. Thank you all for your profound insights into this theme.

Short Bios: