Yahya Sinwar and Prophet Muhammad Discuss the Future

Welcome, everyone, to a truly extraordinary conversation that delves into one of the most complex and heart-wrenching conflicts of our time: the Palestinian struggle. Today, we bring together five voices from across time—Yahya Sinwar, Sheikh Ahmed Yassin, Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi, Yasser Arafat, and the Prophet Muhammad. These leaders, each having played pivotal roles in the history of resistance, join us in an imaginary conversation to discuss a future that transcends war, a future built on peace, unity, and justice.

At the heart of this discussion is a question that all great leaders must grapple with: How do we guide a new generation forward, a generation that has known only conflict, but who dreams of a life of freedom and dignity? These five figures share their wisdom on the role of leadership, the balance between resistance and diplomacy, and how to inspire hope for a brighter tomorrow.

This conversation challenges us to think deeply about the power of love, forgiveness, and faith in a struggle that has lasted for decades. So, open your hearts and minds as we explore a path toward peace and a better future for the Palestinian people.

The Role of Leadership in Liberation Movements

Yahya Sinwar:
"Prophet Muhammad, Sheikh Ahmed Yassin, Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi, Yasser Arafat—today we stand at a critical point in our struggle. Leadership has always played a key role in the fight for our land, but I often wonder, what defines effective leadership in times of conflict? How can we, as leaders, balance the needs of our people with the moral and strategic demands of war?"

Prophet Muhammad:
"Yahya, leadership is a sacred trust. In the Qur'an, Allah commands leaders to act with justice and fairness: 'Indeed, Allah commands you to render trusts to whom they are due and when you judge between people to judge with justice' (Qur'an 4:58). A leader’s duty is not only to guide in times of war but to ensure the well-being of their people in all aspects of life—spiritual, moral, and physical. Effective leadership is rooted in humility, compassion, and the pursuit of peace, even in the midst of conflict. True leadership calls for patience and perseverance, as well as the wisdom to know when to seek peace and when to defend."

Sheikh Ahmed Yassin:
"Leadership in our struggle is not just about tactics or political maneuvering, but about embodying the spirit of resistance for the people. Yahya, when we founded Hamas, it was with the belief that we must lead by example, with strength and steadfastness. The people look to their leaders for guidance and hope. But a leader must also be flexible—ready to adapt to the changing circumstances of the struggle. The goal is always the freedom and dignity of the people, but we must remember that the journey requires both strength and sacrifice."

Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi:
"Yahya, I once believed that strength was the only path to our liberation, and that armed resistance was the only way to defend our people. But now, from the spirit world, I see that there is a greater strength in love, unity, and understanding. Leadership is not about perpetuating conflict but about guiding our people toward a future of peace and reconciliation. I have come to realize that the most powerful leaders are those who inspire hope, not fear, and who lead with compassion rather than anger. It is through peace, built on justice, that true freedom is found."

Yahya Sinwar:
"Abdel, your words carry such weight. Many of our people still believe in resistance through strength and arms, but you speak of peace and love. How do we guide our people toward this path, when so much suffering and anger surrounds them?"

Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi:
"I understand their pain, Yahya. I lived it, and I fought because I believed that was the only way. But now, from where I stand, I see that the truest liberation comes when we free our hearts from hatred. Lead them by showing that peace is not a surrender—it is the highest form of strength. Teach them that the real victory lies in creating a future where their children live in peace, not war. Love for your people means guiding them toward a future where they can live with dignity, but also in harmony with others. The struggle is not over, but it can evolve toward something greater."

Yasser Arafat:
"I, too, always believed that leadership required a balance between resistance and diplomacy. Yahya, the strength of leadership lies in knowing when to fight and when to negotiate, when to defend and when to seek peace. The future of Palestine will be shaped by leaders who are wise enough to know that peace is the ultimate goal. Diplomacy is not weakness, and armed struggle is not the only way. Arafat’s words ring true here. I spent my life pushing for peace alongside the resistance. We must always be ready to seek a path where justice can coexist with reconciliation."

Prophet Muhammad:
"Yahya, as Abdel and Arafat have said, leadership must always serve the greater good of your people. The Qur'an teaches us that 'peace is better' (Qur'an 4:128). Even in the face of injustice, your actions must be guided by the pursuit of peace, tempered by justice. War may sometimes seem necessary, but it must always be a last resort. Lead your people toward a future where they can live without fear, where they can experience the mercy of Allah, which is greater than any conflict."

Sheikh Ahmed Yassin:
"Yahya, it is a difficult path, but leadership requires a vision for the future. You must ask yourself what kind of future you are building for the next generation. Is it one of constant struggle, or one where they can finally live freely, without fear? Our people have fought long and hard, but peace must be the ultimate goal. Strength in leadership means knowing when to fight and when to guide your people toward peace, even if that path is difficult."

Yahya Sinwar:
"I see now that leadership is not only about resisting but about envisioning a future where our people can live in peace. Abdel, your words of love and understanding give me hope. I will lead with the wisdom of knowing that our struggle must not just be for freedom but for peace, built on justice and reconciliation. Thank you all for your guidance."

The Balance Between Diplomacy and Armed Resistance

Yahya Sinwar:
"Prophet Muhammad, Sheikh Ahmed Yassin, Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi, and Yasser Arafat, one of the greatest challenges we face as leaders is deciding when to engage in armed resistance and when to seek diplomatic solutions. Our people are suffering, and many see negotiations as futile, while others believe armed struggle is the only path forward. How do we find the right balance between diplomacy and resistance?"

Prophet Muhammad:
"Yahya, Islam provides guidance on both war and peace. The Qur'an reminds us, 'And if they incline to peace, then incline to it [also] and rely upon Allah' (Qur'an 8:61). Diplomacy is not a weakness; it is a strength when it is used wisely. War is only permitted when injustice and oppression leave no other option, but even then, it must be waged with justice, mercy, and the ultimate goal of peace. You must always strive to find peaceful solutions first, and when resistance is necessary, it should be measured, just, and aimed at restoring harmony."

Sheikh Ahmed Yassin:
"When we began our movement, Yahya, we believed that armed resistance was necessary to defend our people against occupation. But we must also recognize that diplomacy has its place, especially when it offers a path to justice without further bloodshed. There is a delicate balance, and as leaders, it is our responsibility to seek every avenue for peace before resorting to violence. Negotiation does not mean surrender—it is another form of resistance, one that requires wisdom and foresight."

Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi:
"Yahya, I once believed, as many of our people do, that armed resistance was the only way. But now, from where I stand in the spirit world, I see that diplomacy and dialogue can also be powerful tools for achieving justice. Resistance, whether through arms or words, must always be guided by love for our people and the desire to end their suffering. We fought to defend them, but we must also be willing to explore peace when it is possible. Leadership is about knowing when to lay down arms and seek understanding. It is not a sign of weakness, but of great strength."

Yahya Sinwar:
"Abdel, your words have opened my eyes to the possibility of diplomacy in a way I hadn't fully embraced. But many of our people still see negotiations as a betrayal, after years of failed talks. How do we guide them toward believing in diplomacy when they've experienced so much disappointment?"

Yasser Arafat:
"Yahya, I understand their pain. I, too, was often seen as compromising when I pursued diplomacy. But diplomacy is not about betraying your people; it is about fighting for them on a different front. Armed resistance can gain ground, but diplomacy can win lasting peace. The key is to be transparent with your people. They must know that every negotiation is in their interest, and that you are not giving up the struggle, but seeking a way to end it with dignity. Speak to their hearts and remind them that peace is the true victory."

Prophet Muhammad:
"The hearts of the people can be led by truth and faith. As leaders, you must show them that diplomacy is not a surrender, but a continuation of the fight for justice, through other means. The Prophet Musa (Moses) faced great opposition from his people when he led them toward a new path, but he remained steadfast in his mission. Diplomacy requires patience, wisdom, and trust in Allah. You must demonstrate that peace, when based on justice, is the ultimate goal of any resistance."

Sheikh Ahmed Yassin:
"Our people have endured great suffering, and their anger is justified. But as leaders, we must channel that anger into constructive paths. Diplomacy is a tool, just as resistance is. Both serve the same purpose: the liberation and dignity of our people. There are times when we must fight, and times when we must negotiate. Knowing the right time for each is the mark of true leadership. And always, we must remember that peace, when rooted in justice, is the highest form of victory."

Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi:
"Yahya, I once fought with all my heart because I believed that force was the only way. But I now see that peace is a far greater prize. When I look at our people, I see not just their suffering, but their capacity for love, growth, and a future free from war. Armed resistance has its place, but it must always be a means to an end, not the end itself. The balance is in knowing when to shift from resistance to dialogue. Lead with your heart, Yahya. Seek justice through all means available, and never forget that peace is the true liberation."

Yahya Sinwar:
"I understand now that diplomacy is not about abandoning the struggle, but about elevating it. We must resist where necessary, but always be open to peace when it offers a just solution. Thank you all for helping me see that the balance between resistance and diplomacy is not about compromise, but about serving our people in the best way possible."

Unity and Division in the Palestinian Struggle

Yahya Sinwar:
"Prophet Muhammad, Sheikh Ahmed Yassin, Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi, and Yasser Arafat, one of the biggest challenges we face is the division within our own ranks. Different factions have emerged, and we are often fighting not just our external enemies but also among ourselves. How can we unite our people and overcome these internal divisions, especially between groups like Hamas and the PLO? What role does unity play in the success of our struggle?"

Prophet Muhammad:
"Yahya, division weakens any movement, especially one striving for justice. The Qur'an teaches, 'And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided' (Qur'an 3:103). Unity is not only a command but a necessity for success. When the hearts of a people are divided, their enemies find it easier to conquer them. As leaders, your responsibility is to bring people together under a common purpose, and that purpose should always be justice and dignity. Differences will always exist, but you must find ways to reconcile them for the greater good."

Sheikh Ahmed Yassin:
"Our divisions have cost us much, Yahya. When we founded Hamas, it was out of frustration with the direction of the PLO and the belief that armed resistance was necessary. But we must not let these differences undermine the broader goal of liberation. Unity does not mean we all agree on every point—it means we agree on the larger objective of freedom for our people. It is possible to maintain our principles while working together with those who may have a different approach. Leadership means finding common ground, even in times of division."

Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi:
"Yahya, I once believed that our struggle had to be fierce and uncompromising, and that sometimes meant rejecting those who did not agree with us. But now I see that division only makes us weaker. Our people are stronger when we are united, when we work together toward the same goal, even if we have different methods. Hamas, the PLO, and other factions all have the same fundamental aim—freedom for Palestine. Our differences should not tear us apart but drive us to work harder for a solution that respects the vision of all our people. Unity will give us the strength to stand against our enemies and move forward."

Yasser Arafat:
"I understand well the pain of division, Yahya. During my time, I worked tirelessly to unite the various Palestinian factions under the umbrella of the PLO, and it was often a difficult task. But I knew that without unity, our struggle would falter. We may not always agree on how to achieve our goals, but the goal itself must be shared. Diplomacy, armed resistance, and political engagement all play their part, but none of them can succeed without the support of a united people. Our enemies benefit from our internal divisions, and it is our responsibility to bridge the gaps and lead with a vision of solidarity."

Yahya Sinwar:
"But how do we overcome these deep divisions when so much history and ideology separates us? Many in our movement feel betrayed by the compromises made by others, and there is deep mistrust between the factions. How do we rebuild that trust and create a unified front?"

Prophet Muhammad:
"Yahya, trust is built through justice and transparency. As leaders, you must show that you are acting in the best interest of your people, not for personal or political gain. When your people see that you are working for their benefit, trust will follow. Remember the words of the Qur'an: 'Indeed, Allah commands you to render trusts to whom they are due and when you judge between people to judge with justice' (Qur'an 4:58). Lead with fairness and openness, and seek common ground through dialogue. Unity is not built overnight, but it is strengthened when people feel that their leaders are working for the collective good."

Sheikh Ahmed Yassin:
"Rebuilding trust takes time, Yahya, but it begins with dialogue. We must open channels of communication between the factions, not just at the leadership level but among the people themselves. Encourage cooperation in areas where we share common interests—education, infrastructure, and the welfare of our communities. By working together on the ground, we can slowly rebuild trust and show our people that unity is possible, even if we disagree on certain strategies. Leadership means being willing to reach out, even when it is difficult."

Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi:
"Yahya, I agree with Sheikh Yassin. Dialogue and cooperation are essential. But unity also requires humility. We must recognize that none of us holds all the answers. Hamas has its strengths, and the PLO has its own. Together, we are stronger. Leadership is not about demanding that others agree with us entirely; it’s about finding a shared path forward, where everyone’s contributions are valued. The people need to see that their leaders are working for them, not against each other. This is how trust is rebuilt."

Yasser Arafat:
"Unity is not about eliminating differences, Yahya—it’s about managing them. The divisions between Hamas and the PLO, between the different factions, are real, but they do not have to be permanent. We must focus on what unites us—the desire for freedom, the need for justice, and the hope for a future where our people can live with dignity. As leaders, we must always keep this vision at the forefront of our actions. When the people see that we are working toward the same goal, they will follow. It is our duty to lead with unity, even when it is difficult."

Yahya Sinwar:
"I see now that unity is not about erasing our differences but about coming together despite them. We all want the same thing—a free Palestine where our people can live in dignity. Our task as leaders is to show our people that, despite our different paths, we are all fighting for the same cause. We must rebuild trust through dialogue, cooperation, and a shared vision of the future. Thank you all for your guidance."

Vision for the Future of Palestine

Yahya Sinwar:
"Prophet Muhammad, Sheikh Ahmed Yassin, Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi, and Yasser Arafat, we have fought for so long, but the future of Palestine still remains uncertain. How do we guide our people toward a future where they can live in freedom and dignity? What should our vision be for the next generation? What kind of future should we strive to build for Palestine?"

Prophet Muhammad:
"Yahya, the future of any nation lies in the strength of its people and their commitment to justice and peace. The Qur'an says, 'Indeed, Allah will not change the condition of a people until they change what is in themselves' (Qur'an 13:11). Your vision for Palestine should be one rooted in justice, unity, and faith. It is not just about winning battles, but about creating a society where peace, fairness, and dignity reign. The next generation must be taught the importance of compassion, education, and the pursuit of peace. Only then can a lasting future be built."

Sheikh Ahmed Yassin:
"Yahya, our fight has always been for the dignity of our people, but it is time to think about the future beyond the battlefield. The future of Palestine lies in the hearts and minds of our youth. We must equip them with education, values, and a vision for peace. Our resistance was necessary, but it should not be endless. We must build a future where our children can grow up without fear, where they can pursue their dreams and live in freedom. Our vision should be one of a strong, united Palestine—built not just by force, but by the strength of our people’s will and faith."

Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi:
"Yahya, I once believed that the future of Palestine could only be secured through resistance. But now I see that while resistance plays a role, the real future lies in creating a society that thrives in peace. We need a vision that goes beyond war—a vision where our people can rebuild, where they can live with dignity, and where the next generation can inherit a country that offers them hope. We must invest in education, infrastructure, and healing the wounds of our long struggle. The future of Palestine is not just in resisting our enemies, but in building a nation that stands strong in peace."

Yasser Arafat:
"I have always believed that the future of Palestine is tied to peace. Our people deserve to live in freedom, but that freedom must be built on justice and diplomacy. We cannot win by force alone; we must win the hearts and minds of our people and the world. Our vision should be one of a free and independent Palestine, where our people can live with dignity, side by side with their neighbors. This means investing in the future—building schools, fostering a culture of dialogue, and ensuring that our people are educated and empowered to lead. The future of Palestine is in the hands of the next generation, and it is our duty to guide them toward peace and unity."

Yahya Sinwar:
"But how do we inspire the next generation to believe in a peaceful future when they have grown up surrounded by conflict and hardship? Many of them are angry, and they see violence as the only way forward. How can we give them hope for something better?"

Prophet Muhammad:
"Yahya, hope is born from faith and vision. Teach the next generation that peace is not a sign of weakness but a path to lasting strength. Show them that justice can be achieved through patience and perseverance. The Prophet Musa (Moses) faced great adversity, but his faith in Allah guided him and his people to freedom. You must lead with compassion and show them that their future can be different from their past. Inspire them with a vision of a Palestine where they are free to grow, to learn, and to build their own future. It is through education and unity that you will give them hope."

Sheikh Ahmed Yassin:
"The youth need direction, Yahya. They need to see that there is more to their future than war. It is our job as leaders to give them opportunities—to educate them, to engage them in building their communities, and to show them that peace is possible. The next generation will carry our struggle forward, but they must also learn how to build a future beyond resistance. By empowering them, we can guide them toward a future of freedom and peace."

Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi:
"Yahya, I understand the anger of the youth—I felt it myself for many years. But anger alone cannot guide a nation. We must channel that energy into something productive, something that builds rather than destroys. The youth need to see that their future is not limited by the conflict of the past. We must give them the tools to build a better life—through education, through dialogue, and through creating a strong society that is resilient, even in peace. We must guide them toward healing, not just fighting."

Yasser Arafat:
"Peace is the key to our future, Yahya. The next generation needs to see that peace is possible, and that their lives can be more than just a continuation of the struggle. We must invest in their education, their well-being, and their opportunities. Show them that diplomacy, dialogue, and unity are the ways to secure their freedom. Our vision for Palestine must be one of a free and independent state, where our people live in peace and dignity. We must give them hope by showing them that their future is not defined by the conflicts of the past."

Yahya Sinwar:
"I see now that our vision for the future of Palestine must go beyond resistance. We must build a nation where our people can live in peace, where our children can grow up with hope, and where justice and dignity are at the heart of everything we do. I will strive to lead with this vision in mind, to inspire the next generation to believe in a future where peace is not just a dream, but a reality. Thank you all for your guidance."

Short Bios:

Yahya Sinwar:
Yahya Sinwar is the current leader of Hamas in the Gaza Strip and a prominent figure in the Palestinian resistance. He has played a significant role in shaping the political and military strategies of Hamas in their struggle for Palestinian independence.

Prophet Muhammad:
The Prophet Muhammad is the founder of Islam and the final messenger of Allah. His teachings form the basis of the Qur'an and have guided billions of Muslims in matters of faith, morality, and justice.

Sheikh Ahmed Yassin:
Sheikh Ahmed Yassin was the co-founder and spiritual leader of Hamas. Known for his strong advocacy for Palestinian resistance, he inspired generations to continue the fight for Palestinian rights until his assassination in 2004.

Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi:
Abdel Aziz al-Rantisi was a co-founder of Hamas and a key political leader. He was known for his unwavering support for armed resistance against Israeli occupation until his assassination in 2004. In this conversation, he speaks from a place of peace and reflection.

Yasser Arafat:
Yasser Arafat was the leader of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) and a key figure in Palestinian politics for decades. Arafat sought to combine diplomacy and resistance in his pursuit of an independent Palestinian state and was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for his role in peace negotiations.